He’s posted a 6.75 ERA in his last four outings, allowing five homers, 21 hits and 21 runs over that span (24 innings).
That’s a huge difference from the way he started the season. Bauer was dominant, allowing just nine runs and posting a 1.99 ERA in six starts (40.2 innings).
"He just hasn’t commanded the way he needs to,” manager Terry Francona said. “There’s been a few outings, he just hasn’t commanded. When he commands, he’s fine. He gets us deep into games and he gets the strikeouts.”
There’s no doubt Bauer is one of the best pitchers in baseball. He’s been dominant for the past year and a half. There are adjustments he will have to make, but the Indians believe he’ll turn things around.
“We’re going to figure it out. He’s going to be good. I’m not worried about him.”
The advanced numbers look even worse for Bauer. He’s issuing 4.31 walks per nine innings this season, which is much higher than the 2.93 walks he averaged last season. The 4.31 average would be the highest of his career. Bauer has allowed 1.11 home runs per nine innings, which is much closer to his 2017 output (1.28) than last season (0.46). His home run to fly ball ratio is 13.6 percent, which is over double what it was in 2018 (6.2 percent).
It’s a small sample size and he was pitching at a high level a month ago, but his struggles are real. That doesn’t mean he won’t turn it around, but it does mean Francona can no longer pencil him in for a quality start.
“I've got to be ahead of the count, putting guys on the defensive instead of behind and working my way back in, letting guys feel comfortable in the box,” Bauer said on Thursday. “That starts with throwing quality pitches on 0-0 counts and working ahead. I've just got to be better at that.”
The Indians need Bauer to be great, which means he’s going to have to fix the issues he’s had in recent weeks. No one knows that more than him.
“I’ve got to do better. My teammates, the organization, the fans depend on me. They count on me to go out and be better than I am right now.”