Andrew grew up in upstate New York. He graduated from Syracuse University where he served as the talk show director at historic student radio station, WAER. In 2008 and 2009, he hosted, anchored and reported for WGR 550 in Buffalo. In 2010, he moved to Pittsburgh and began hosting at 93.7 The Fan.
Since 2018, Andrew’s hosted “The PM Team with Poni and Mueller” in afternoon drive. Previously, he hosted the “Cook and Poni Show” with Pittsburgh Post-Gazette columnist Ron Cook and a weekly show with Steelers quarterback Ben Roethlisberger.
In addition to radio, he’s a regular contributor on KDKA-TV’s “Sports Showdown” and KDKA-AM.
Beginning in 2016, Andrew has served a variety of roles for CBS Sports Radio. His national show, “The Poni Express”, airs Sunday mornings across the CBS Sports Radio network and 93.7 The FAN HD-3.