The ongoing copyright dispute with designers Harrison/Erickson, Inc. kickstarted talk of updating the Phanatic's look, says Tom Burgoyne, the man inside the green fur for the last 32 years.
"Nobody really likes change," Burgoyne said. "I think it kind of kickstarted the discussion. But the fact is, the Phanatic has always changed and evolved over the years," Burgoyne said.
Are these design changes sufficient to resolve the Phillies' legal fight over who created the furry creature? Probably not, says Pepper Hamilton intellectual property attorney Peter Wakiyama.
"Generally speaking, if you create something that's based on someone else's work, that's a derivative. And the owner of the work has an exclusive right to create derivatives," Wakiyama said.
What's more, Burgoyne says, fans in Clearwater's Spectrum Field, who got the first look, are seeing the same old mischievous mascot.
"When he came out on the four-wheeler — and always gets a great response. And it really was like: There was no change. The Phanatic is still the same old Phanatic. He's cruising around on his ATV. He was spilling a lot of popcorn yesterday. His bigger butt kind of was getting in the way of some fans."
While the legal fight plays out, Burgoyne says he believes that, over time, fans will see the mascot as the same old Phanatic.